Voidly
All findingsPublished research

Cohort migration tracker: which countries are shifting DTW censorship cohorts over time

Voidly Atlas already clusters the 50 highest-signal countries into DTW cohorts — C1 stable democracies, C2 bursty, C3 persistent authoritarian — by daily-signal SHAPE similarity under Dynamic Time Warping. But that clustering was a one-shot snapshot: it told you where a country sat, never whether…

Read the full published summary

Voidly Atlas already clusters the 50 highest-signal countries into DTW cohorts — C1 stable democracies, C2 bursty, C3 persistent authoritarian — by daily-signal SHAPE similarity under Dynamic Time Warping. But that clustering was a one-shot snapshot: it told you where a country sat, never whether it had moved. The cohort migration tracker closes that gap. It recomputes the cohorts on a rolling 90-day window every month, compares the new assignment to last month's, and emits the list of countries that crossed cohorts — with a direction-of-travel label (deteriorating / improving / lateral) and a per-country fit confidence. A country sliding C1→C3 is one of the cleanest leading indicators of a censorship regime change we can compute. The hard part is stable cohort identity: re-running clustering reassigns arbitrary cluster IDs, so the tracker gives each cluster a stable semantic label from anchor-set overlap (CN/RU/IR/MM pull toward C3; US/GB/DE/FR/CA pull toward C1) plus centroid burstiness. First snapshot pair (90d-now vs 90d-30d-ago, both from real evidence): 6 countries changed cohort. Four deteriorated C1→C3 — Nigeria (conf 0.53), Zimbabwe (0.51), Mexico (0.50), Slovenia (0.46) — and two improved C3→C1: Iraq (0.68) and Venezuela (0.66). Honest caveats baked into every response: DTW silhouette is only ~0.38 (modest separation, cohorts overlap), a cohort shift can be data-driven rather than regime-driven (treat as a signal to investigate not a verdict), and the monthly cadence will miss faster transitions. Live at GET /v1/atlas/cohort-migration; per-country history at /v1/atlas/cohort-migration/{cc}; rebuilds monthly on the 1st at 06:00 UTC.

What this is

Voidly Atlas already clusters the 50 highest-signal countries into DTW cohorts — groups of countries whose daily censorship-signal shapes look alike under Dynamic Time Warping (scripts/build-shutdown-cohorts-dtw.py). DTW is the right distance here because it tolerates time-shifted phases: country A can block an app three days before country B and still land in the same cohort. The three recurring archetypes are C1 (stable democracies), C2 (bursty), and C3 (persistent authoritarian).

But that clustering was a snapshot. It told you where a country sat today, never whether it had moved. The cohort migration tracker (scripts/build-cohort-migration-tracker.py) closes that gap: it recomputes the cohorts on a rolling 90-day window every month, compares the new assignment to last month's, and emits the list of countries that crossed cohorts — with a direction-of-travel label and a fit confidence.

Why a cohort shift matters

A country sliding from C1 → C3 — from a democracy-shaped signal pattern to an authoritarian-shaped one — is one of the cleanest leading indicators of a censorship regime change we can compute. It is not proof of anything on its own, but it is exactly the kind of structural shift a journalist or a human-rights researcher wants flagged early. The reverse move (C3 → C1) is just as newsworthy: it can mark a shutdown resolving or a country exiting a crisis posture.

The hard part: stable cohort identity

Re-running clustering from scratch reassigns arbitrary cluster IDs — “cluster 1” last month is not “cluster 1” this month. Comparing raw IDs across runs is meaningless. The tracker fixes this by giving each cluster a stable semantic label derived from its composition: anchor-set overlap (CN/RU/IR/MM… pull a cluster toward C3_authoritarian; US/GB/DE/FR/CA… pull it toward C1_democracy) plus centroid burstiness (the fraction of days more than 1.5σ above the cluster mean). That makes “C3 authoritarian” a stable noun across runs even when the underlying member list shifts month to month.

What the first run found

The first snapshot pair compares the 90-day window ending today against the 90-day window ending 30 days ago — both computed from real evidence. Six countries changed cohort.

Four moved in the deteriorating direction (C1 → C3): Nigeria (confidence 0.53), Zimbabwe (0.51), Mexico (0.50), and Slovenia (0.46). Two moved the other way, improving (C3 → C1): Iraq (confidence 0.68) and Venezuela (0.66). The improving moves carry higher confidence here, which is itself a signal worth reading honestly: the four deteriorating countries land near the decision boundary between cohorts rather than deep inside C3.

Read this honestly

Every caveat ships inline in the API response. The most important ones:

  • The DTW silhouette on the 90-day window is around 0.38 — modest separation. The cohorts overlap; a country near a boundary can flip on noise.
  • A cohort shift can be data-driven — a change in how much evidence we collected for a country — rather than regime-driven. Treat a migration as a signal to investigate, never a verdict.
  • The monthly cadence will miss faster transitions: a multi-week shutdown that opens and resolves between two snapshots leaves no trace in the migration list.
  • The labels {democracy, bursty, authoritarian} are derived from an anchor set plus a burstiness threshold. They encode our prior, not ground truth.

How to use it

GET /v1/atlas/cohort-migration returns the recent cohort changes; filter with ?direction=deteriorating or ?min_confidence=0.5. GET /v1/atlas/cohort-migration/{cc} returns one country's cohort history, one entry per monthly snapshot, so you can see the trajectory. GET /v1/atlas/cohort-migration/info documents the cohort labels, the severity ranking, and the methodology. The tracker rebuilds monthly on the 1st at 06:00 UTC; the history retains up to 24 snapshots.

The source record.

Original source links and labels. Linked responses may have changed since publication.